THE INTEGRITY OF AFFIDAVITS AND COURT RECORDS

22 November 2026
Evidence Integrity | Court Records | Procedural Fairness | Judicial Accountability | Rule of Law
UTS Law's #LegalLingo series recently highlighted a fundamental legal concept: an affidavit is a written statement of evidence sworn or affirmed to be true.
The term affidavit originates from medieval Latin, meaning “he or she has sworn”, derived from affidare, meaning “to pledge faith”. Its origins reflect the solemn undertaking behind sworn evidence and the importance of preserving its authenticity and integrity.
But what happens when the authenticity of affidavit exhibits or other court documents is called into question?
Key Takeaways
Sworn evidence: Affidavits are formal statements sworn or affirmed to be true.
Documentary integrity: Original evidence must not be improperly altered, removed or substituted.
Legal consequences: Unauthorised interference with evidence may raise serious questions of criminal liability and professional misconduct.
Procedural fairness: Disputed documentary evidence may affect the fairness of proceedings and requires appropriate judicial consideration according to its relevance and the applicable law.
Rule of law: The integrity of sworn evidence and court records is essential to the administration of justice.
Table of Contents
1. What is an Affidavit?
An affidavit is a written statement of evidence made by a person, known as the deponent, who swears or affirms that its contents are true.
Affidavits, commonly used in civil proceedings, may be accompanied by annexures or exhibits containing documents relevant to the matters addressed in the sworn statement.
Witness evidence may also be given through oral testimony under oath or affirmation, subject to the applicable rules of evidence and procedure.
The significance of an affidavit lies not merely in its written form, but in the formal undertaking that the evidence is true.
This distinguishes sworn evidence from ordinary correspondence, informal statements and other documents not made under oath or affirmation.
2. Preserving the Authenticity and Integrity of Sworn Evidence
Once an affidavit has been sworn or affirmed, its contents and associated exhibits cannot simply be altered, removed or substituted. Any amendments must follow proper legal procedures.
No one, including the deponent, opposing parties, legal representatives or judicial officers, may unilaterally alter original documents and present them as the original sworn evidence.
The distinction between an original document and a subsequently amended or corrected version must remain identifiable.
These safeguards are essential because courts, parties and witnesses must be able to ascertain precisely what evidence was sworn or affirmed and what material was placed before the Court.
Similar principles of authenticity and integrity apply to statutory declarations and other formal declarations of truth, including those submitted to oversight bodies.
Even seemingly minor unauthenticated alterations, such as substituting a page with an identical-looking copy that was not part of the original affidavit sworn or affirmed by the deponent, may call the authenticity, reliability or admissibility of documentary evidence into question, depending on their nature and significance.
3. Unauthorised Interference with Evidence and Court Documents
Most people would never imagine affidavit evidence being improperly interfered with. Yet concerns about such interference can arise in court proceedings.
Unauthorised interference with affidavit evidence, exhibits or court documents may have serious legal consequences.
In a NSW Court of Appeal leave-to-appeal proceeding, the applicant raised concerns about alleged alterations to affidavit exhibits and other court documents.
The applicant placed before the Court the parties' respective document folders for comparison, together with written submissions and a table identifying the alleged discrepancies.
The applicant also referred to section 317 of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW), concerning interference with evidence, to explain the potential seriousness of the matters raised. This reference did not establish that an offence had occurred.
The applicant contended that the identified discrepancies had not been substantively explained in the respondent's submissions.
The applicant further contends that the judgment did not engage with the documentary material identified in the applicant's submissions.
4. Judicial Responsibility and the Integrity of Court Records
A leave-to-appeal proceeding has a different and more limited function than a trial or criminal investigation. The Court was not being asked to determine criminal liability.
Nevertheless, where concerns about documentary authenticity are material to the issues requiring determination, their significance warrants appropriate judicial consideration within the scope of the proceedings.
Not every allegation requires a separate judicial determination. However, the treatment of material documentary discrepancies may have implications for procedural fairness, the adequacy of judicial reasons and the integrity of the judicial record.
Depending on the circumstances, interference with evidence or court documents may raise questions concerning:
The authenticity, reliability and admissibility of evidence.
Procedural fairness and the parties' ability to respond to the evidence.
Compliance with court rules and professional obligations.
Potential criminal liability, including offences relating to interference with evidence.
The integrity of the judicial record and the administration of justice.
The integrity of court records is not merely an administrative concern. It is fundamental to judicial accountability, appellate review and public confidence in the administration of justice.
5. Why Documentary Integrity Matters
Three principles deserve particular emphasis.
First, authenticity must be preserved. A sworn document should remain identifiable in the form in which it was made, together with any properly recorded corrections or amendments.
Second, allegations must be distinguished from findings. Concerns about documentary interference require evidence and proper examination. An allegation alone does not establish wrongdoing.
Third, judicial records must remain reliable and intelligible. The parties, appellate courts and, where appropriate, the public must be able to understand the evidence and documentary material relevant to judicial determinations.
These principles are fundamental to the rule of law because the administration of justice depends not only upon the application of legal rules, but also upon the integrity of the evidentiary record to which those rules are applied.
6. Summary
Affidavits are solemn statements of evidence sworn or affirmed to be true. Their authenticity and integrity must be preserved throughout judicial proceedings.
Unauthorised alteration, removal or substitution of sworn evidence or court documents may have serious legal and procedural consequences, depending upon the circumstances.
Where concerns about documentary integrity arise, they must be assessed according to the evidence, the applicable law and the procedural context.
The integrity of sworn evidence and court records is fundamental to procedural fairness, the administration of justice and the rule of law.
Marie Odtojan | Legal Commentary & Opinion.
Disclaimer: This article is published for public information, legal education and commentary on matters concerning the administration of justice and the rule of law. It reflects the author's legal analysis and opinions and does not constitute legal advice. References to particular proceedings, documentary discrepancies or alleged conduct are not assertions that criminal offences or professional misconduct have been established unless expressly supported by a judicial or other competent determination.






































Comments