OPEN JUSTICE | When a Judgment Is Not Enough: Judicial Transparency in the UK and NSW

18 November 2026
PUBLIC INTEREST | ACCESS TO COURT RECORDS | ACCOUNTABILITY | RULE OF LAW
Summary
A recent report by the Law Society Gazette “Lawyers told to release skeleton arguments and witness statements” highlights developments in England and Wales aimed at improving public and media access to written submissions, witness statements and other court documents.
This provides a striking contrast with recent reporting concerning Freund v Attorney General of NSW [2026] NSWCA 232, in which NSW Court of Appeal Justices Mark Leeming and Anthony Payne reportedly refused media requests for access to transcripts and tendered evidence, despite no reported suppression order preventing access.
The reported explanation that sufficient information was already publicly available raises a fundamental question:
Can a published judgment provide sufficient transparency when the underlying court records necessary for independent scrutiny remain inaccessible?
The issue extends beyond any individual proceeding. It concerns open justice, judicial accountability and public confidence in the administration of justice.
Key Takeaways
UK developments: Initiatives in England and Wales are improving access to written submissions, witness statements and other court materials, subject to appropriate safeguards.
NSW Court of Appeal: Media requests for access to transcripts and tendered evidence in Freund were reportedly refused despite no suppression order.
NSW's own procedures: Practice Note SC Gen 2 ordinarily provides for non-party access to certain categories of material used in open court, subject to judicial discretion.
Judicial accountability: Open justice requires meaningful opportunities to scrutinise judicial proceedings, not merely access to published judgments.
The central question: What justifies restricting access to court records from public proceedings, and how does that restriction accord with open justice?
Table of Contents
England and Wales: Advancing Access to Court Documents
On 16 November 2026, the Law Society Gazette published Catherine Baksi's article, “Lawyers told to release skeleton arguments and witness statements.”
The report discussed remarks by Mr Justice Nicklin, chair of the judiciary's Transparency and Open Justice Board, concerning the importance of making written submissions and witness statements accessible to journalists.
The article raised concerns about the risk of “secret justice” where important materials relied upon in public proceedings are not accessible to the media.
Recent UK initiatives include:
A civil Court of Appeal initiative facilitating access to skeleton arguments in selected proceedings.
The Access to Public Domain Documents Pilot, operating from 1 January 2026 to 31 December 2027 in specified commercial courts and lists.
Wider consideration of measures to improve public understanding of judicial proceedings.
Under Practice Direction 51ZH, the Commercial Court pilot provides a structured mechanism through which non-parties can access specified documents used or referred to in public hearings, including skeleton arguments, written submissions, witness statements and expert reports.
Access remains subject to judicial control, confidentiality protections and other applicable restrictions.
These developments recognise an important distinction: access to judicial reasons is not necessarily equivalent to access to the materials upon which those reasons are based.
NSW Court of Appeal: When the Judgment Is Considered Sufficient
In reporting published by The Australian on 14 November 2026, Janet Albrechtsen raised concerns about media access to court records in Freund v Attorney General of NSW [2026] NSWCA 232.
According to the report, Justice Mark Leeming declined an initial request for access to transcripts and tendered evidence. A subsequent request was reportedly declined by Justice Anthony Payne.
The newspaper reported that no suppression order prevented access to the requested material.
The reported explanation was, in substance, that sufficient information was already available to understand the case.
That explanation raises important questions.
A judgment is the Court's account of its reasoning and conclusions. It does not necessarily reproduce every submission, evidentiary issue or document placed before it.
A judgment cannot independently verify itself.
How can journalists or members of the public independently examine the accuracy and completeness of a judgment's account of proceedings without access to the relevant underlying materials?
The publication of judicial reasons is an essential component of open justice. But it does not, by itself, resolve whether access to the relevant court records should be granted or refused.
As discussed in our previous article, Open Justice in Question: Media Refused Access to NSW Court of Appeal Records the reported refusals raise questions about the practical ability of the media to scrutinise proceedings involving judicial accountability and public institutions.
NSW's Own Framework: Access to Court Files
New South Wales already has established procedures governing access to court records.
Supreme Court Practice Note SC Gen 2 - Access to Court Files, which expressly applies to the Court of Appeal, provides that access to court files by non-parties requires leave of the Court.
Importantly, clause 7 provides that access will normally be granted to non-parties for specified categories of material, including:
Documents recording what was said or done in open court;
Material admitted into evidence; and
Information that could have been heard or seen by a person present in open court, subject to applicable restrictions.
This does not create an unrestricted entitlement to every document or transcript. The Court retains discretion, and legitimate grounds may justify withholding access.
Nevertheless, where media access to records of public proceedings is refused, particularly in the absence of a suppression order, important questions arise:
What legal and procedural considerations justified the refusal?
What interests warranted restricting access?
How does the refusal accord with the principles and procedures governing open justice?
The absence of a suppression order does not automatically establish an entitlement to access. Equally,
the existence of judicial discretion does not eliminate the importance of transparency and accountability in its exercise.
The UK Comparison: Open Justice in Practice
The developments in England and Wales demonstrate that greater documentary transparency can be pursued through structured procedures while preserving safeguards for confidentiality, privacy and the proper administration of justice.
NSW's own Practice Note similarly recognises circumstances in which non-parties will normally be granted access to court materials.
The issue, therefore, is not simply whether one jurisdiction has better rules than another.
It is how the principles of open justice are applied in practice.
Where proceedings concern judicial officers, public institutions or matters of substantial public interest, access to the underlying record may be particularly important for informed reporting and independent scrutiny.
Written submissions identify the arguments advanced. Evidence and exhibits reveal the material placed before the Court. Transcripts record what occurred during proceedings.
Restricting access to those materials can limit the public's ability to understand and examine the administration of justice.
Open justice is not absolute. But restrictions on access should be capable of principled justification.
Reflections
The recent UK developments provide a timely opportunity to reflect on documentary access in NSW courts.
While England and Wales are pursuing initiatives to improve access to materials used in public proceedings, the reported refusals in Freund raise questions about the practical operation of open justice in New South Wales.
The central issue is not whether every document must automatically be released.
It is whether restrictions on access are sufficiently justified, particularly where proceedings have been conducted publicly and no suppression order prevents disclosure.
Who determines what information is sufficient for the public to scrutinise judicial proceedings? On what basis? And how can the administration of justice be independently examined when access to the underlying records is refused?
Open justice is fundamental to judicial accountability, public confidence and the rule of law.
It must be meaningful in practice, not merely acknowledged in principle.
Related Article
OBL Open Justice in Question: Media Refused Access to NSW Court of Appeal Records - Freund v Attorney General of NSW 14 November 2026.
Catherine Baksi, “Lawyers told to release skeleton arguments and witness statements”, Law Society Gazette, 16 November 2026. https://www.lawgazette.co.uk/news/lawyers-told-to-release-skeleton-arguments-and-witness-statements/5128547.article
Freund v Attorney General of NSW [2026] NSWCA 232, judgment delivered 30 October 2026. https://www.caselaw.nsw.gov.au/decision/1a189ab8a64941c4283663c0
Janet Albrechtsen, “Treatment of Local Court judge by Judicial Commission reeks of elite legal club protecting its own”, The Australian, 14 November 2026.
Supreme Court of NSW, Practice Note SC Gen 2 - Access to Court Files.
Courts and Tribunals Judiciary (England and Wales), Practice Direction 51ZH - Access to Public Domain Documents.
Marie Odtojan | Odtojan Bryl Lawyers | Odtojan Bryl Justice Project | Public Legal Education and Independent Commentary - Judicial Transparency in the UK and NSW
Disclaimer: This article is independent public-interest legal commentary. The discussion of media access in Freund v Attorney General of NSW is based on published reporting. The comparison with England and Wales concerns developing transparency initiatives and does not suggest that unrestricted access is available in either jurisdiction. This article does not constitute legal advice.



































Comments