top of page

RULE OF LAW IN QUESTION: When the Complainant Becomes the Accused

1 day ago
3 min read

Updated: 17 minutes ago


Judge Penelope Wass SC, DPP Sally Dowling SC and NSW Attorney-General Michael Daley. The Wass–Dowling–Daley saga continues: NSW Attorney-General refers Judge Wass to the Judicial Commission as questions surrounding parliamentary findings concerning DPP Dowling and institutional accountability remain unresolved.
The Wass–Dowling–Daley saga continues: NSW Attorney-General refers Judge Wass to the Judicial Commission as questions surrounding parliamentary findings concerning DPP Dowling and institutional accountability remain unresolved.

Published 17 November 2026

Rule of Law | Accountability | Institutional Integrity | Legal Commentary


“The Judge Who Can’t Get Justice for Herself” - Hugh Selby | CityNews, 12 November 2026


In a detailed commentary, former barrister and CityNews legal affairs columnist Hugh Selby examines the continuing controversy involving NSW District Court Judge Penelope Wass SC, Director of Public Prosecutions Sally Dowling SC and NSW Attorney-General Michael Daley.


What began with allegations concerning the disclosure of sensitive information by the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (ODPP) to the media about a child's criminal sentencing proceedings has developed into a controversy involving parliamentary scrutiny, institutional accountability and a subsequent complaint against the judge who raised concerns.


The controversy has also attracted an editorial in The Australian, “Daley’s feud threatens confidence in NSW justice system” (11 November 2026), raising wider concerns about prosecutorial accountability, judicial independence and public confidence in the administration of justice.


Key Takeaways


  • The original allegations: Judge Wass alleges that the ODPP deliberately supplied misleading information to radio station 2GB concerning her handling of an Indigenous child's sentencing proceedings, contrary to its media guidelines. Selby describes the information provided by the ODPP to the media as misleading and inflammatory.


  • Unresolved accountability: Despite reports to multiple authorities and a parliamentary inquiry, Selby questions why those responsible for authorising the disclosure have not been publicly identified and held accountable.


  • Parliamentary scrutiny: Selby questions the failure of key witnesses to cooperate fully with inquiries. He also cautions that the parliamentary committee's majority findings went beyond what the evidence established, observing that “suspicion, however strong, is not proof.”


  • Parliamentary findings and accountability: The parliamentary inquiry, originally established to examine identity protections for children, made adverse majority findings concerning DPP Sally Dowling SC and recommended that the Attorney-General consider establishing a formal inquiry into whether grounds existed for her removal from office. The proposed inquiry would have provided a further process for examining the allegations and testing the evidence. The Attorney-General instead commissioned a separate review and declined to establish the recommended formal inquiry, raising questions about whether the underlying allegations have been adequately and independently examined and resolved.


  • The Attorney-General's response: Selby raises concerns about the Attorney-General's reported consultation with the DPP regarding the appointment of a reviewer of the parliamentary committee's adverse findings.


  • Independent oversight: The Australian editorial identifies what it considers a significant gap in NSW's institutional framework: the absence of a satisfactory mechanism for independently examining serious allegations about prosecutorial conduct.


  • Inversion of Capacity: When the Complainant Becomes the Accused: Judge Wass, having raised serious concerns and pursued lawful reporting processes, subsequently became the subject of a complaint lodged by Attorney-General Michael Daley with the NSW Judicial Commission, as reported by The Australian in November 2026. This matter raises questions about whether accountability mechanisms can themselves be used as instruments of retaliation.


Reflections


The fundamental question is: Is it safe to make a lawful report or complaint about suspected misconduct or wrongdoing, particularly when those concerns involve people in positions of power, authority or professional responsibility?


When a person raises serious concerns through lawful processes, only to become the subject of allegations or investigations themselves, how do we distinguish legitimate accountability from possible retaliation or the weaponisation of institutional processes?


And where serious allegations concern those in positions of authority, what safeguards ensure that investigations are independent, decisions are evidence-based, and statutory powers and discretion are exercised lawfully, fairly, in good faith and for proper purposes?


These questions are not confined to the judiciary. They extend to the legal profession, regulatory bodies, public institutions and any setting where individuals exercise professional or institutional authority.


The rule of law cannot be selective.


The existence of statutory powers and discretion does not place their exercise beyond scrutiny. Nor should institutional independence become a shield against legitimate accountability.


We frequently hear the rule of law invoked by those entrusted with administering justice.


But the true test is whether its principles are consistently upheld, particularly when those exercising power are themselves called to account.


Is the rule of law meaningful in practice, or merely performative?


🔗 Articles and references:


Disclaimer: This post is for public information and commentary only. Allegations, findings and opinions are distinguished where relevant. It does not constitute legal advice. Wass-Dowling-Daley

Comments


Featured Posts
Recent Posts
Search By Tags
  • Facebook Classic
  • LinkedIn App Icon
  • Twitter Classic
  • Google Classic
Follow Us
  • Facebook Metallic
  • LinkedIn Metallic
  • Twitter Metallic

Information on this website is not legal advice.

Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.

 © 2024 All rights reserved for Odtojan Bryl Lawyers.

bottom of page